While you have a higher score than each of your opponents, this dilemma is cost -3. Unless you have Biology, 2 Diplomacy, and 2 Science or 2 Engineer, 2 Exobiology, and Cunning>38, randomly select two personnel to be killed.
"Take charge of the evacuation, we'll meet you in The Forge as soon as we can."
Image courtesy of trekcc.org
No copyright infringement intended